In the 1800s, P.T. Barnum used to promote the arrival of the circus with parades and clowns and band wagons through the town. By the late 1800s, politicians were noticing the excitement generated by the band wagons, and they would ride their own band wagons through town to generate support and excitement for the campaigns. Supporters would climb aboard, and the phrase “jump on the band wagon” was born.

So it seems fair to say, even back then, politicians were imitating clowns.

Over time, the phrase has come to mean rallying around any popular cause, clowns or no clowns.

And with the new statewide Freelance Isn’t Free Act, signed by Gov. Hochul on Nov. 22, the State of New York has done just that. New York’s statewide adoption of this freelancer law follows similar laws enacted in Illinois, New York City, Los Angeles, Minneapolis, Seattle, and Columbus. You can compare the four cities’ laws here and read more about Illinois’ law here.

Here’s what the NY State version will require, any time there is a contract with an individual independent contractor for services valued at $800 or more, either for one project or an aggregation of projects over 120 days:

• Written contract required, which must include:
  • Name and address of hiring party and contractor
  • Itemization of services
  • Value of services
  • Rate and method of compensation
  • Date payment is due, or how due date will be determined
  • Any deadline by which the contractor must submit a list of services provided so that the hiring party can timely process payment.
• The hiring party must provide a copy of the contract to the contractor.
• The hiring party must retain the contract for six years!
• Payment to the contractor must be made by the deadline specified in the contract or, if no deadline is specified, then within 30 days after the services have been completed.
• The hiring party cannot require the contractor to accept less than the contracted amount. (The law does not seem to provide any exception for unsatisfactory services.)
• Retaliation is prohibited against any contractor who seeks to exercise rights under the Act.

If there is a dispute over whether timely payment was made, the burden of proof is on the hiring party.

The law creates a private right of action.

The penalty for failing to provide a written contract is $250, if the contractor requested the written contract. Such a claim must be brought within two years.

The penalty for failing to make payment as required by the law or under the contract is the value of the contract, plus double damages, plus attorneys’ fees, and possibly injunctive relief. The statute of limitations for this type of claim is six years.

Waivers of any right under this Act are void as against public policy.

The law takes effect on May 20, 2024, and it will apply to contracts entered into after that date. In December 2022, Gov. Hochul vetoed an earlier version of this law, finding that it imposed too great a burden on the NYSDOL. Those concerns have been resolved in the new version of the Act.

The law does not apply to contracts with independent sales representatives, lawyers, medical professionals, or construction contractors.

The law applies not only to businesses, but to anyone in New York State who retains an independent contractor. As we discussed here when the New York City version of the law was enacted in 2017, the Act applies even to babysitters and dog walkers, if the minimum compensation amount is met.

Businesses and individuals who retain individual independent contractors in New York State, Illinois, Los Angeles, Minneapolis, Seattle, and Columbus need to know their obligations under these laws and act accordingly.

The Freelance Isn’t Free laws do not weigh in on whether the contractor is properly classified as an independent contractor.

There is a clear trend toward passing these types of laws, and we can expect more cities and states to jump on the band wagon.

© 2023 Todd Lebowitz, posted on WhoIsMyEmployee.com, Exploring Issues of Independent Contractor Misclassification and Joint Employment. All rights reserved.